Research evidenceResearch evidence — scores and sourced research

Scored entertainment-first on WhatSphere's content-balance model 3

Its director stated on the record that "we wanted someone who would do something original, unexpected — something that was a surprise to us, Benedict brought something completely unique to Smaug" 1. Its narrative-universality assessment registers 8 of 10 2. Taken together, the content-balance model places it entertainment-first at 7 of 100 3. Relative to the expected cast make-up for its production origin, on-screen representation registers above the baseline for White and below it for Asian 4.

The receipts — every claim above is sourced
  1. 1
    Creator statementdirector: "We wanted someone who would do something original, unexpected — something that was a surprise to us. Benedict brought something completely unique to Smaug."CBR / Peter Jackson interview on The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug source ↗
  2. 2
    Narrative universalityNarrative universality 8 of 10; identity centrality incidental.WhatSphere content assessment. Narrative universality 8/10 -> advocacy signal 22
  3. 3
    Content balanceAdvocacy 7 of 100, tier entertainment-first.WhatSphere content-balance model, score_version 1. Narrative universality 8/10 -> advocacy signal 22
  4. 4
    RepresentationRepresentation vs production-origin baseline: White 92, Asian 31.WhatSphere representation model, score_version 1

WhatSphere presents the sourced record; it does not cast the judgement. Every statement above is drawn from a stored, sourced row — shown beside it — and nothing is asserted beyond what those receipts support.

Data updated March 22, 2026Scored, pending verification.Think a score is wrong? Submit a correction.
Primary audienceYoung MenYoung Men80
Young MaleYoung FemaleMature MaleMature Female
Primary audienceYoung Men
Targeted

Quadrant Scores

Young Men
80
Young Women
45
Older Men
56
Older Women
20
Loading factors...

Audience Representation

White
92
Black
46
Hispanic
48
Asian
31
South Asian
42
Middle Eastern
46
Indigenous
40
Mixed
40
Other
48
LGBTQ+
0

Faithfulness

Faithfulness not applicable

Faithfulness is scored only for adaptations.

Why this is blank

An original has no source text to compare. The score is left blank rather than shown as zero.

Advocacy

Advocacy7
Entertainment

Where to Watch (US)

Stream
HBO MaxHBO MaxHBO Max Amazon ChannelHBO Max Amazon Channel
Rent
Amazon VideoAmazon VideoApple TV StoreApple TV StoreGoogle Play MoviesGoogle Play MoviesYouTubeYouTubeFandango At HomeFandango At HomePlexPlex
Buy
Amazon VideoAmazon VideoApple TV StoreApple TV StoreGoogle Play MoviesGoogle Play MoviesYouTubeYouTubeFandango At HomeFandango At Home

View streaming options ↗

Synopsis

The Dwarves, Bilbo and Gandalf have successfully escaped the Misty Mountains, and Bilbo has gained the One Ring. They all continue their journey to get their gold back from the Dragon, Smaug.

Score version: v1Data confidence: 100%How are scores calculated?

What did the audience think? Rate The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug — every voice counts equally, no account needed. Clean reviews appear instantly.

Lineage and popularity

No lineage or popularity yet

This title has no Wikidata match, source work, or Steam player snapshot. A missing snapshot is not zero.

Compare The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug

Put its audience profile side by side with any other title.

Compare with…Across the Lord of the Rings franchise

Advocacy Over Time in Fantasy

The average advocacy score of Fantasy titles by release year, with this title marked. Higher is more advocacy-driven.

25507519402026
Average advocacy score of Fantasy titles by release year
YearAverage advocacyTitles
194022
197002
197702
197832
198202
198416
198532
198603
198715
198815
198942
199005
199114
199244
199323
199435
199524
199602
199733
199826
199926
200024
200179
200272
200337
200476
200527
200638
200728
200867
200954
201063
201164
2013105
201452
2016246
2017176
2018103
20191912
2020244
2021118
20222215
20233011
202468
2025616
20261110
This title (2013)71

● This title (2013): advocacy 7 · explore Fantasy →

Cast & Crew

Oliver Ferguson (director) · Simon Bright (director)