Evidence dossierThe evidence dossier — both sides, by the receipts

James Gunn said Peacemaker challenges political divides with compassion and that John Cena improvised a hyper-sexual open Christopher Smith 1 2.

The critical side argues Peacemaker is Gunn sermonizing about American division under a gross-out superhero shell 1. The defending side argues the show is about friendship love and comedy that happened to open Peacemaker sexually through improv 2 4. Gunn said the country has political divides and he feels compassion even for people he disagrees with heartily 1. Gunn said Cena improvised a hyper-sexualized dude open to anything sexually and he was surprised 2. Danielle Brooks said it is important to have Black women in this space and she had never seen anyone like herself 3. Gunn said at the heart is a love of friendship between Adebayo and Smith 4. WhatSphere scores advocacy 16 of 100 entertainment-first with identity present and LGBTQ centrality 2 5. Whether gross-out satire with queer-open leads is message-first is a values dispute once the on-record compassion frame is fixed 1.

The receipts — every claim above is sourced
  1. 1
    Creator statementPolitical divides; compassion including for people he disagrees withThe Playlist, 2022 source ↗
  2. 2
    Creator statementCena improvised hyper-sexual open PeacemakerEmpire / Out.com, Feb 2022 source ↗
  3. 3
    Creator statementBlack women needed in this space; never seen herselfVariety, Jan 2022 source ↗
  4. 4
    Creator statementHeart is friendship love between Adebayo and SmithDeadline / IGN, Jan 2022 source ↗
  5. 5
    Content balanceAdvocacy 16 entertainment-first, identity present, LGBTQ 2WhatSphere scores

WhatSphere presents the sourced record; it does not cast the judgement. Every statement above is drawn from a stored, sourced row — shown beside it — and nothing is asserted beyond what those receipts support.

Data updated March 13, 2026Scored, pending verification.Think a score is wrong? Submit a correction.

Synopsis

The continuing story of Peacemaker, a vainglorious superhero/supervillain who believes in peace at any cost — no matter how many people he has to kill. After a miraculous recovery from his duel with Bloodsport, Peacemaker soon discovers that his freedom comes at a price.

Young MaleYoung FemaleMature MaleMature Female
Primary audienceYoung Men
Targeted

Quadrant Scores

Young Men
96
Young Women
32
Older Men
68
Older Women
4
Advocacy16
Entertainment

Audience Representation

White
49
Black
68
Hispanic
33
Asian
56
South Asian
46
Middle Eastern
48
Indigenous
48
Mixed
42
Other
48
LGBTQ+
21

Where to Watch (US)

Stream
HBO MaxHBO MaxHBO Max Amazon ChannelHBO Max Amazon ChannelTNTTNT
Buy
Amazon VideoAmazon VideoGoogle Play MoviesGoogle Play MoviesFandango At HomeFandango At Home

View streaming options ↗

Score version: v1Data confidence: 100%How are scores calculated?

What did the audience think? Rate Peacemaker — every voice counts equally, no account needed. Clean reviews appear instantly.

Compare Peacemaker

Put its audience profile side by side with any other title.

Compare with…

Advocacy Over Time in Action

The average advocacy score of Action titles by release year, with this title marked. Higher is more advocacy-driven.

25507519642026
Average advocacy score of Action titles by release year
YearAverage advocacyTitles
196402
196543
196604
196822
197002
197104
197202
197319
197503
197722
197903
198035
198103
198205
198307
1984211
198507
1986210
1987114
198804
1989010
199005
199109
199218
1993011
1994214
1995111
199609
1997213
1998010
1999113
2000111
2001120
2002117
2003214
2004219
2005318
2006123
2007118
2008222
200929
201038
2011312
2012510
2013416
201469
2015716
2016159
2017917
2018920
20191118
20201013
20211025
20221532
20231225
2024831
2025435
2026816
This title (2022)161

This title (2022): advocacy 16 · explore Action

Cast & Crew